Credit where it's due before anything else: the Batwing isn't my design. It's Barry G4MKT's twin end-fed, and all I did was build one — with rather less finesse than Barry would have managed. His version tunes up on every band without an ATU. Mine leans on the tuner here and there, which I'm told has caused Barry some genuine angst. Fair enough.
The idea
Take two wires of different lengths and feed them against each other at a high-impedance point through a 36:1 transformer. Each wire is a half-wave, or a whole number of half-waves, on a different set of bands, so between them one feed point finds a resonance at or near every band from 80m to 10m. No traps, no stubs, no switching: just two well-chosen lengths of wire. It's a lovely piece of thinking — and it's good enough that, Top Band aside, it's the only antenna Barry needs.
My legs are about 41 m and 29 m. The long one is a half-wave on 80m and a full wave on 40m; the short one is a half-wave on 60m and a full wave on 30m. They started life at right angles in an L, and these days run east–west in a straight line, 180° apart — hence the name. The feed point is at 7 m, and each leg rises to about 12 m at its midpoint before dropping back to 7 m at the far end.
The model shows the trick beautifully. Here's the current along the wires (the blue line) on 60m and on 80m, with the feed point in the middle:
60m: the short leg (left) lights up as a half-wave; the long leg barely joins in.
80m: now the long leg (right) does the work.
Each band picks its own leg, and the feed point sits at a current minimum — a high-impedance point — on all of them. That's what lets one 36:1 transformer serve the lot.
My build, and how it differs
My feed box: the 36:1 transformer at the top, with the two legs on the red and black posts and a small compensation capacitor across the low side; below it a coax common-mode choke on its own ferrite ring.
Same idea, same ratio, but not quite the same hardware. My transformer is wound 12:2 on two stacked FT240-43 cores; Barry's uses a single FT240-43 with more turns — which, as it happens, works out at much the same inductance, so the boxes are closer than they look. Barry's also carries a chain of resistors to bleed off static, a nice touch I didn't copy.
The real difference is a refinement Barry added that I didn't. A wire's harmonic resonances never land exactly on multiples of its fundamental — the full-wave resonance always sits a little above twice the half-wave one. Barry pulls them back into line with small series capacitors placed along the legs — and it's this, with a little patience, that lets his version work without a tuner at all. At a leg's midpoint, the half-wave mode has its current peak and the full-wave mode has a null, so a capacitor there moves the fundamental and leaves the harmonic alone; at the quarter and three-quarter points it's the other way round. Choose the spots and values carefully and every band lands where you want it. Mine has no capacitors at all — I did model one once, but never got round to fitting it.
What the VNA says
The whole antenna, swept through the feed box. Amateur bands shaded; dashed line is 2:1.
Swept through its feed box with the miniVNA and the Radio Cockpit VNA tool, the Batwing shows a dip at or near every band from 80m to 10m — Barry's idea doing exactly what it says. The 80m and 60m resonances sit right in their bands, at 3.73 and 5.32 MHz, both comfortably under 2:1. 10m comes good too, with a 1.24:1 dip at 28.93 MHz. 40m has a lovely 1.14:1 dip — but at 7.40 MHz, a couple of hundred kilohertz above the band, which is exactly what you'd expect from a harmonic left to its own devices — and exactly what Barry's capacitors are there to fix. On the higher bands the dips are there but shallower, which I put down to my lack of patience with the tuning rather than the design; I also suspect my two cores lose a little more up there than Barry's one. Where it's not flat, the SPE's tuner takes care of it without a second thought.
So the next experiment is obvious: add Barry's capacitors, a step at a time, with a VNA sweep after each. I'll report back on how close I can get mine to his.
How it does on the air
In my shack the Batwing plays a slightly different role from Barry's. With the Hexbeam taking over from 20m up, I've made it my low-band special — 80, 60, 40 and 30m, plus Top Band. It does still get plenty of use everywhere else, though: when the SPE is switched off it defaults to antenna socket 1, which is the Batwing, so for casual listening it's often what I'm hearing on every band.
Here's the thing that matters most: it works, and it works well. I do a lot of side-by-side comparisons with the DX Commander, and the Batwing often wins on signal strength and SNR — most obviously on NVIS signals. The DX Commander still gets most of my FT8, because it's omnidirectional and should be better at low angles for DX — though that's theory rather than anything I've proved.
The Batwing also gets me onto Top Band through an MFJ-948B manual tuner, and what it's really doing down there is a story of its own — see The Road to a Top Band Dipole.
So: thank you, Barry, for a clever design that works for both of us. And if I can get mine to behave like yours, you'll be the first to know.
No comments:
Post a Comment